• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Polycentric Leadership

Collaborative, communal leadership empowering multiple centers of influence

  • About
  • Traits
    • Charismatic
    • Collaborative
    • Communal
    • Relational
    • Entrepreneurial
    • Diverse
  • Articles
  • Resources
    • Case Studies
    • Video
    • White Papers
  • Book
    • Press Release
    • From Author
    • Endorsements
    • Book Reviews
  • Requests
Who’s in Charge

Polycentric Leadership / 3-June-2024

Who’s in Charge

GUEST POST BY BRENT FULTON

When Christians from China take the gospel to other nations, they encounter a double-edged cultural challenge. Not only do they need to adjust to the language and customs of their new host country; they must also negotiate relationships with Christian workers from other parts of the world with whom they will be serving.

As one believer from China related to me last year, this latter cultural encounter highlights the difference in approach between the Western task-oriented mindset and the relational emphasis of many Chinese missionaries. Armed with decades of experience, proven methods, advanced technological tools, and considerable financial backing, workers from established international organizations have a clear idea of what needs to be done and how it should happen.

Yet, he noted, “A lot of Western organizations now have the realization, ‘We need to let them be in charge; let them lead.’”

But how?

“Chinese workers don’t know a lot about how to reach the people group,” he explained. “They don’t have a professional perspective on Bible translation, media production, or such things. They only want to be able to stay there, to be accepted by the local people, have friendships, and share the gospel. It’s very simple.”

Given their fundamentally different expectations on the field, it is no surprise that when either party attempts to call the shots it inevitably results in misunderstanding and disappointment.

Furthermore, this brother pointed out, “Since they are new, I don’t think they are able to lead, in many ways…. They don’t have the competence [to be] a qualified missionary.”

Passing the Baton

“Passing the baton” has long been a staple in the vocabulary of Western Christians’ China narratives. From James Hudson Taylor’s metaphor of missionaries as “scaffolding,” to optimistic proclamations about China’s church taking the gospel back to Jerusalem, foreign workers have served with the expectation that their Chinese colleagues would eventually take the lead.

But if efforts on the field are largely the product of strategies, budgets, and priorities set in agency boardrooms thousands of miles away, how can the workers from China be expected to lead? Multiply this tension by the number of different agencies represented on any given field, and it is no wonder this brother from China, when asked about partnering with international organizations, said, “It’s overwhelming.”

Instead of trying to figure out who’s in charge, he prefers “a co-laboring partnership.”

“We are together for God’s kingdom, not for organizational goals, not for the field workers to be successful. It’s for expanding God’s kingdom…to reach more people. So I think it’s a kingdom mindset…. We are mutually partnering.”

Polycentric Leadership

For what this could look like in practice, we might turn to the work of Joe Handley, Allen Yeh, and other missiologists who have suggested a new approach to leadership. As it turns out, it is actually not so new. Handley and co-author Micaela Braithwaite write,

Christianity is the only religion which has no single holy place, no city or country that we attribute greater spiritual significance to, or which represents our faith. There is also no majority ethnic group or one culture which depicts our beliefs. Even the Scriptures were written by numerous different authors, from different geographic locations, and the Gospel accounts of Jesus’ life are an interweaving of different accounts into a single narrative. Embedded in Christianity is the idea of polycentrism.1

Polycentric, or “many-centered,” leadership enables a community of people from different backgrounds, operating in collective fashion and inspired by the Holy Spirit, to utilize their unique gifts and potential. Handley sees polycentric leadership as a welcome corrective to the historic unidirectional view of missions, often articulated as “from the West to the rest.” He describes it as neither centralized nor decentralized, but as a hybrid structure in which power and decision-making are diversified within a network of individuals unified by a single goal.

In a discussion with Handley, Francis Tsui, a Christian business leader in Hong Kong, pondered the relevance of polycentric leadership to the current Chinese mission movement, particularly as it relates to the broader Lausanne vision for global evangelization:

I observe that the Chinese church is still struggling in how to situate itself [in] its role in global mission. How close they should work with established West-based mission movements and organizations (and infrastructure), or should they develop their own missiology, infrastructure, and mechanism? There are still many differing opinions on both sides of the arguments….

It is not about what and how Lausanne may like to lead/serve, but, rather, how the Chinese church might like to drive. Maybe there, in fact, is a wider application of polycentrism in missional development.2

As with many Christian China narratives, the questions we ask shape the storyline. If “Who’s in charge?” is not the right question, attempts to answer it will undoubtedly prove unsatisfactory.

Perhaps a better starting point would be, “How shall we lead together?”

Dr. Brent Fulton
A3 Council of Reference

 

More Information

  • Originally published by ChinaSource https://www.chinasource.org/resource-library/blog-entries/whos-in-charge/
  •  Cover image courtesy of China Source

Endnotes

  1. Joseph W. Handley and Micaela Braithwaite, “What is Polycentric Leadership?” Lausanne Movement, September 20, 2022, accessed May 23, 2024, https://lausanne.org/about/blog/what-is-polycentric-mission-leadership.
  2. Joseph W. Handley, Polycentric Mission Leadership: Toward a New Theoretical Model for Global Leadership (Oxford: Regnum Books International, 2022), 90.

_________________________

Brent Fulton is the founder of ChinaSource. Dr. Fulton served as the first president of ChinaSource until 2019. Prior to his service with ChinaSource, he served from 1995 to 2000 as the managing director of the Institute for Chinese Studies at Wheaton College. From 1987 to 1995 he served as founding US director of China Ministries International, and from 1985 to 1986 as the English publications editor for the Chinese Church Research Center in Hong Kong.

Dr. Fulton holds MA and PhD degrees in political science from the University of Southern California and a BA in radio-TV-film from Messiah College. An avid China watcher, Dr. Fulton has written and taught extensively on the church in China and on Chinese social and political phenomena. He is the author of China’s Urban Christians: A Light That Cannot Be Hidden and co-authored China’s Next Generation: New China, New Church, New World with Luis Bush.

Please follow and like us:
error
fb-share-icon
Tweet

Filed Under: Guest Post Tagged With: Allen Yeh, Brent Fulton, China, ChinaSource, Francis Tsui, Hudson Taylor, Joseph Handley, Micaela Braithwaite, missionaries, Polycentric Leadership

You may also like

Endorsements World Evangelical Alliance Mission Commission (Polycentrism): Our Missions Future. Navigating the Seas of Change

Case Studies

  • The Humility Test
    PART 6 » Promod Haque explains why humility, teachability, and collaboration are among the most important qualities leaders can possess in high-stakes environments. [more…]
  • Wisdom for the Next Generation
    PART 5 » Promod Haque shares practical leadership advice for the next generation, highlighting the importance of operational experience, learning from failure, and building strong teams. [more…]
  • When Centralized Models Fail
    PART 4 » The dot-com crash exposed the dangers of concentrating too much knowledge, authority, and investment in a single area. Promod Haque explains how diversification created resilience. [more…]
  • Trust Across Differences
    PART 3 » Promod Haque shares why humility, mentoring, collaboration, and trust are essential ingredients for distributed leadership and healthy polycentric organizations. [more…]
  • The Power of Diversification
    PART 2 » How can organizations thrive through disruption and uncertainty? Promod Haque explains how intentional diversification helped Norwest Venture Partners build resilience and embody polycentric leadership. [more…]

White Papers

  • Diverse as a Foundational Theme of Polycentric Leadership
    Explore how diverse leadership strengthens polycentric systems by valuing varied perspectives, empowering contextual leadership, and integrating cultural differences to foster innovation, resilience, and mission-aligned collaboration across global networks. [more…]
  • Entrepreneurial as a Foundational Theme of Polycentric Leadership
    Explore how entrepreneurial leadership strengthens polycentric systems by empowering distributed initiative, adaptive experimentation, and mission‑aligned risk‑taking that drive innovation and responsiveness across decentralized contexts. [more…]
  • Relational as a Foundational Theme of Polycentric Leadership
    Relational leadership places trust, mutual accountability, and deep connection at the center of influence, making it essential for effective polycentric leadership. By prioritizing relationships over hierarchy, it strengthens collaboration across cultures and organizations, enabling decentralized networks to stay aligned, resilient, and missionally focused in complex global environments. [more…]
  • Communal as a Foundational Theme of Polycentric Leadership
    Explore the Communal theme of Polycentric Leadership, showing how shared identity, mutual responsibility, and collective discernment shape trust, resilience, and long-term sustainability in decentralized leadership systems. [more…]
  • Collaborative as a Foundational Theme of Polycentric Leadership
    Collaboration sits at the core of polycentric leadership, enabling authority, decision‑making, and accountability to be shared across interconnected centers. This paper explores how collaborative practices strengthen coherence, adaptability, and trust in complex, multi‑layered organizations. [more…]

Book Reviews

One Seed Many Soils: Remembering Sadiri Joy Tira

28-October-2026 By Joseph Handley

A friend who made room for others, and the book he conceived in a hospital bed By JOSEPH W. HANDLEY, Jr., Ph.D. I promised Dr. Sadiri …

[Read More...] about One Seed Many Soils: Remembering Sadiri Joy Tira

Book Review: Joseph W. Handley, Jr., Polycentric Mission Leadership: Toward a New Theoretical Model for Global Leadership

30-June-2026 By Polycentric Leadership

BOOK REVIEW BY TIANJI MA Published in Global Missiology, www.globalmissiology.org, April 2025 Joseph W. Handley Jr. (2022). Polycentric …

[Read More...] about Book Review: Joseph W. Handley, Jr., Polycentric Mission Leadership: Toward a New Theoretical Model for Global Leadership

Book Review: The Covenant Quarterly

22-May-2024 By Polycentric Leadership

Covenant Quarterly 81:2 - https://covquarterly.com/index.php/CQ/issue/view/25/7 Polycentric Mission Leadership - Book Review Joseph W. …

[Read More...] about Book Review: The Covenant Quarterly

Primary Sidebar

Discover Polycentric Leadership

Check out Polycentric Mission Leadership for an innovative look into the 21st-century mission vision. Available for purchase at Regnum Books, Amazon and Barnes & Noble. …

Read more » about Book

Press Kit

  • Bio
  • Images & Logos
  • Interview Requests
  • Link Tree
  • About the Book
  • Order Book

Recent Posts

  • The Humility Test
  • Wisdom for the Next Generation
  • When Centralized Models Fail
  • Trust Across Differences
  • The Power of Diversification
  • The Unexpected Path
  • Leading from the Margins: Polycentric Transition in Cross-Cultural Ministry
  • One Seed Many Soils: Remembering Sadiri Joy Tira
  • How the Assemblies of God Rediscovered the Peoples of the World
  • What COMIBAM Teaches Us About Polycentric Leadership

Categories

  • Book Reviews
  • Case Studies
  • Charismatic
  • Collaborative
  • Communal
  • Diverse
  • Endorsements
  • Entrepreneurial
  • Guest Post
  • PCL Traits
  • Polycentric Leadership
  • Relational
  • Video
  • White Papers

Popular Topics

A3 Allen Yeh Asia book book review case studies case study charismatic christian leadership church collaboration collaborative DAO decentralization definition distributed leadership diverse entrepreneurial executive leadership innovation Joseph Handley Kirk Franklin Lausanne Lausanne Movement leader development leadership leadership lessons leadership model leadership principles management Mary Lederleitner missiology mission MissioNexus Noel Becchetti Norwest Venture Partners partnership polycentric Polycentric Leadership Promod Haque teams traits trinitarian trust Video

Continue the Discussion

Let’s talk further. Feel free to connect with me on social media or via email. You can find out more here… 

  • •  Joe Handley’s blog
  • •  Joe Handley’s bio

Stay Updated

Get new posts by email...

Footer

Follow PCL

RSS
Follow by Email
Facebook
Facebook
fb-share-icon
Twitter
Visit Us
Follow Me
Post on X
LinkedIn
LinkedIn
Share
YouTube
YouTube
Set Youtube Channel ID
Instagram

Search

Copyright © 2020–2026 Polycentric Leadership · Design by HCS · Log in

  • About
  • Articles
  • Book
  • Resources
  • Privacy
  • Contact